Metal vs. Asphalt: Which Roofing Handles Michigan Snow & Ice Better?

Michigan winters are no joke, and if you live in the Livonia, Canton, and Brighton areas, snow, sleet, and ice can pile up fast. Roofs in this part of the state have to handle heavy snow loads, freezing temperatures, and constant cycles of melting and refreezing. That combination can quickly expose weak spots, leading to leaks, ice dams, and costly repairs. 

If you’re a Michigan homeowner, you already know the toll winter can take on your roof. But which material stands up best when the snow starts to fall—metal or asphalt shingles? In this guide, we’re comparing the performance of Michigan metal and asphalt roofs in winter to help you decide which is better for protecting your home. 

Comparing Asphalt Shingle & Metal Roofing in MI 

Let’s compare asphalt shingle and metal roofing products using some key performance categories: 

Snow-Shedding Ability 

When it comes to snow removal, metal roofs have a clear advantage. Their smooth surface allows snow and ice to slide off more easily, reducing buildup that can strain your roof. Asphalt shingles, on the other hand, tend to hold onto snow longer. That extra weight can put more stress on your roof deck. 

Ice Dam Prevention 

Ice dams form when heat escapes through your attic, melting snow on the roof. When that melted snow refreezes near the edges, it can block drainage and cause water to seep under shingles. Metal roofs are naturally better at preventing ice dams because their slick surface allows meltwater to run off quickly. Asphalt roofs are more prone to trapped water, which can worsen leaks and cause hidden damage over time. 

Long-Term Costs & Durability 

Both materials can perform well if properly maintained, but their long-term value differs. Asphalt shingles are more affordable upfront, making them popular with many homeowners. However, they typically last around 20 to 25 years. Metal roofs can last twice as long, or more, with minimal upkeep. Over time, that means fewer replacement and repair projects, even in harsh winter conditions. 

So, which is better? Both roofing types can protect your home through Michigan’s winter if installed and maintained correctly. But when comparing strength, longevity, and resistance to snow and ice, metal roofing edges out asphalt as the more durable choice overall. 

We Offer Durable Asphalt & Metal Roofing Options 

At JW Roofing, we install both asphalt shingle and metal roofing systems designed to deliver maximum protection and performance. Whether you prefer the classic look of shingles or the modern appeal of metal, we’ll help you find the perfect fit for your home and budget. 

Our asphalt roofing options provide dependable protection and timeless curb appeal. We use advanced GAF shingles built to resist wind, moisture, and temperature swings. With proper maintenance, these roofs perform reliably in all weather conditions, from hot summers to snowy winters. 

Our metal roofing systems combine strength and efficiency. Available in styles such as metal shingle, metal tile, metal shake, and vertical panels, these roofs offer outstanding durability and energy performance. They’re ideal for homeowners who want better ice dam prevention and long-term resistance against rust, wind, and water damage. 

JW Roofing is proud to be a GAF Master Elite Contractor, meaning our installers receive advanced training and can offer exclusive warranty coverage on materials and workmanship. With decades of experience, hundreds of 5-star reviews, and a reputation for providing honest, personalized service, we’re a trusted choice for homeowners throughout Michigan.  

Learn More About Our Roofing Options 

If you’re ready for a new roof and comparing the performance of metal and asphalt roofs in Michigan winters, the next step is to talk to the experts who know the local climate inside and out. If you live in the Livonia, Canton, or Brighton areas, JW Roofing can help you choose a roof that stands strong against snow, ice, and freezing temperatures—while still fitting your budget and style preferences. 

Reach out to us today to schedule a no-obligation consultation so we can answer your questions and tell you about the convenient financing options that are available.